Our Offices
Medical Negligence

Case Study: X v Y

28 January 2025

Case Study: X v Y

P.A. Duffy and Company Solicitors recently acted in a Clinical Negligence case and secured a settlement of £59,000.00 on behalf of the Plaintiff (X). 

Naomi White, Solicitor, led by Gary Potter KC dealt with a case involving a problematic wisdom tooth extraction procedure. 

The Plaintiff (X) attended the Defendant's (Y) clinic for a tooth extraction. Y advised X that they would carry out the extraction themselves, without conducting a comprehensive assessment of X or informing X of the risks and complications which were associated with this form of treatment. Y failed to appropriately consider any other treatment which X had previously and conducted a non-diagnostic radiograph which inadequately displayed the position of the inferior dental nerve - a critical factor to ensure a safe extraction. The extraction took place, and X left the clinic with exposed nerves and diminishing anaesthesia resulting in excruciating pain. 

X visited their local Accident and Emergency Department and was prescribed a course of antibiotics. At this stage, X was experiencing numbness in the face. Unhappy with the situation, X attended hospital for a Radiological assessment which revealed that due to the current situation, it would take some months for a full examination.

The overall mishandling of the procedure, lack of appropriate radiographic assessment, absence of nursing assistance, prolonged and painful extraction and failure to arrange necessary follow-up appointments led to prolonged pain, discomfort and numbness for X.

X instructed P.A. Duffy and Company Solicitors and secured settlement in the sum of £59,000.00.

If you have been adversely affected throughout the course of medical or dental treatment, please get in touch with our expert team today.

P.A. Duffy & Co

Speak to us with no obligation

Confidential legal advice from experienced solicitors across Ireland.

028 8772 210232-36 May Street, Belfast, BT1 4NZ

Want to talk?

Call us with any queries

028 8772 2102

Mon – Fri, 9am – 5pm

Make an Enquiry

Leave your details below and we'll get in touch with you as soon as possible!

SEO& Web design byVudu